Horseradish Sauce Recipe

Make your own Horseradish sauce! It’s super easy. This recipe for horseradish sauce goes perfect with prime rib.


  • 4 tablespoons prepared horseradish in vinegar or 4oz jar
  • 1 cup sour cream
  • ½ cup milk
  • ¼ cup mayonnaise
  • 1 teaspoon kosher salt
  • Zest of 1 lemon


Mix horseradish, sour cream, milk, mayo, salt, and lemon in bowl. Refrigerate at least 24 hours before serving.

What Is Horseradish, Anyway?

Most of us have tasted — or at least smelled — horseradish. Did you know that the horseradish plant is a cousin of radishes, wasabi and cabbage? The vegetable’s leaves can be eaten, although it is most popular for its large root.

The root in and of itself is hardly exciting. But when grated, it produces a pungent aroma and accompanying taste. Over time, it loses its bite unless it has been saturated in a preparation made with another liquid, such as vinegar. In addition to being eaten fresh, horseradish can be dried.

If you plan on using fresh horseradish to make your horseradish sauce, be sure to take precautions. Many people prefer to wear gloves when handling freshly grated horseradish, much in the same way they handle jalapeños or other pepper varieties. Not sure you want to grate your horseradish root by hand? Pulse it in your food processor for the perfect bite.

Places to Use Easy Horseradish Sauce

Once you get the hang of making your signature creamy horseradish sauce based on our recipe, you may find that it goes well in a few different dishes. Below are some of our favorite uses for easy horseradish sauce:

  • Add a dollop alongside sliced, cooked ham. Ham and horseradish are a marriage made in hog heaven!
  • When you want to give your tuna salad sandwich a kick, mix horseradish sauce with mayo as the moist base for the salad. No other seasoning will be necessary.
  • Are you known for making the most devilish deviled eggs on the block? Kick them up a notch with a spoonful of horseradish.
  • Speaking of eggs, quiches and omelets come to life when they are babied by a little horseradish sauce on top.
  • Treat yourself to a feisty potato salad with lots of festiveness by mixing horseradish sauce into the main ingredients. Pull back on some of the mayo — you won’t need it!
  • Create the best sandwiches for your lunch by choosing horseradish sauce as your condiment of choice.
  • Dip grilled, smoked shrimp in horseradish sauce instead of tomato-based cocktail sauce.

Tips to Making Unique-to-Your-Backyard Horseradish Sauce

Looking for ideas to jazz up your horseradish sauce or just make it taste slightly different than the general recipe? First, switch from prepared horseradish to freshly grated horseradish. If you want to lower the fat content in your horseradish sauce, change from sour cream to Greek yogurt. You can also swap lowfat mayonnaise for the full-fat variety.

Are you lactose intolerant or getting away from dairy? Soy, almond, oat or even coconut milk is a great sub for cow’s milk. And lime or grapefruit can take the place of lemon if you feel like going in a fun tropical direction.


Referenced Products

Grilla Wood Pellet Smoker Grill

The Grilla Pro wood pellet smoker grill features convection grilling airflow for Pro-Smoke barbecue smoke flavor. Grilla's EvenTemp Chamber, Keep Heat Swing Lid and Never Flare Flavor Disk produce a consistent heat and smoke level in the cooking chamber.

Rack Extension (Grilla)

Grill for the entire jungle with a Grilla Grills rack extension for the Grilla. Takes your grilling space from 488 square inches to 630 square inches. Easy to install, 1/4 inch Stainless rack allows for even more valuable cooking space for all of your BBQ grillin' endeavors.

All Purpose Rub 12 oz.

If you're looking to add versatility and flavor to your BBQ, grab a bottle of Grilla Grills All Purpose Rub. Recommended by pro team grill members, Grilla Grills All Purpose BBQ Rub contains the perfect blend of spices to up your grillin' game.
Grilla Grills
558 E. 64th Street
Holland, MI 49423
Phone: 616-392-7410